Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Graham Linehan's avatar

Thanks to Frankie for this--you can complain here bsuh.genderinclusionmidwives@nhs.net

Expand full comment
Una-Jane Winfield's avatar

Those 2 paragraphs from the 3 CCGs (2 xNottingham and Rushcliffe) are absolutely WRONG. The person who wrote this garbage for CCGs should be sacked!

(1) Embryology

Testosterone is produced by the foetus, not the mother. In a foetus with normal XY chromosomes (i.e. male) the Sry gene on the Y chromosome works normally to produce a burst of testosterone at the appropriate time to induce development of male genitalia. There is no Sry gene on X chromosomes, so a foetus with XX chromosomes develops to the "default" sex which is female.

(2) There are differences in the hypothalamus, but it is down (again!) to SEX not "gender".

"The hypothalamus is one area of the brain with well-documented differences between men and women. Two areas of the hypothalamus, the preoptic area and the suprachiasmatic nucleus, have clear differences in female and male brains...... Preoptic Area of the Hypothalamus: This area of the hypothalamus is involved in mating behavior. In males of several species including humans, the preoptic area is greater in volume....Suprachiasmatic Nucleus of the Hypothalamus: This area of the hypothalamus is involved with circadian rhythms and reproduction cycles. The only difference between women and men in this area is one of shape..." (From: Neuroscience for kids - https://faculty.washington.edu/chudler/heshe.html) No mention of a "developing gender" or "sex in the brain".

Who gave the author this rubbish? Mermaids? The CCGs give out funds to Hospitals. I hope they do it better than the way they study embryology.

Expand full comment
9 more comments...

No posts