53 Comments

So a women who cannot give birth and a women who looks masculine are to be considered the same as a man with no surgery whatsoever who simply id’s as a women, fucking infuriating and fucking offensive. How can someone even write that down and not see it!

Expand full comment
Sep 7, 2021Liked by Graham Linehan

Shahrah Ali has my vote. Joined the greens especially to cast it!

Expand full comment

Me too! xx

Expand full comment

And me.

Expand full comment

Same here.

Expand full comment

And me

Expand full comment

Ditto!

Expand full comment

If Shahrar sweeps in, expect a big boost from labour, lib dem and undecided women joining the ranks...

Expand full comment

Put this question out about 8 times today...on the Judith Butler thread.

What is a woman?

Only one answered back....

English Lit prof; bisexual English Scot

James Purple heart Loxley

@oldnorthroad

Sep 7

after a series of tweets

"I love the way you think this is some kind of gotcha, Rosie. In some ways it’s admirable that you’ve got your one thought, and you’re sticking to it."

they all know what a women is...

they are full blown cowards sacred of being cancelled.

Expand full comment

Which Judith Butler thread, Sian? On Twitter?

Expand full comment

yes it was on trending twitter …her Guardian article

Judith Butler: ‘We need to rethink the category of woman’

Jules Gleeson

The author of the ground-breaking book Gender Trouble says we should not be surprised when the category of women expands to include trans women

https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2021/sep/07/judith-butler-interview-gender

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

Yes. That article is. I am sick of Butler and her ilk expanding and expanding our decreasing rights from under us. What about women's names Judith?

I was too distracted by the most shared Graun article today on the light sentence given to a man who would never hurt the women he killed during sex, but it's ok as he doesn't really remember and never hurt her before, honest. Mysterious that this keeps happening then. Despite the government telling them the rough sex 'defence' is not to be used anymore as no one can consent to their own bodily harm and death. If you can bear it read it, the names and the stories of the women at #WeCantConsentToThis and #CountDeadWomen and #CountingDeadWomen

Expand full comment

Kat Bristow @KathrynBristow https://twitter.com/KathrynBristow

"Polyam ace pan t4t genderfae female person RainbowTransgender flag Mixed/Black.

Disabled. ADHD/OCD/Dyspraxia/Dyslexia. Depression/Anxiety.

Views belong to me. Fae/Faer"

Honest, I am NOT making this up! :0) << sideways smiley face.

Could someone please explain to him you have to be BORN female to be female, although, I recall him telling folks, re filling in The Census, that 'truth' is what you perceive it to be. He'd ticked 'female', as I recall. He's now going to sue The Green Party for being horrid/horrid/ to him, because....all together now...because he's 'trans'.

Expand full comment

How the f*ck do you use fae/faer in conversation? How do you even start to reprogramme your brain to do this? What do they even mean? They sound like they've been taken from Lord of the Rings!

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

I'm so pleased to hear Bristow lost. The more he loses the better I like it.

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

Yes! Here's hoping.

Expand full comment

I saw that, made me gag!

Expand full comment

Can you imagine a bunch of dudes answering what is a man? How many would say that women can be men? Or say 'intersectional' BS! None is the answer.

Women are a fucking disgrace.

Apart from GC ones obvz.

Expand full comment

Voted today 😉

Expand full comment

Did Womack say "I talk a lot about inter-sexual feminism..." ?? I've listened to it 3 times now and I'm sure she did. I thought "intersectional" was the approved adjective - but this is more honest :)) These young women selling out other women's rights to gain power for themselves - just shocking. I know who gets my vote.

Expand full comment

Cannot believe her ridiculous throwing of toys.. she didn’t once answer a question succinctly. Sharar was cool and informed (I voted for him 😉) and the way she then uses the fact she is a ‘woman’ to try shit him down! Oh she knows what a woman is when it suit her. She came across as a petulant child, ‘no debate! No debate!’.. if she gets elected god help us all!

Expand full comment

I couldn't listen for very long she was so childish and annoying. Just had a run-in with a BDSM dentist yesterday, have very low tolerance today.

Expand full comment

*shut! Damn predictive text 😵‍💫

Expand full comment

in this instance the predictive text worked quite well!

Expand full comment

I guess you’re right 😂

Expand full comment

Well yhere you have it accordin tae Cleo Lake "Being a woman is an attitude". Simples. 🥴😁🤣

Expand full comment

She fails to clarify what that attitude is sadly.

Expand full comment

Surely it makes no sense to question what a woman is if you are not also going to question what a man is? It just goes to show how one-sided this all is. Men are not being told that they are just a "feeling".

Expand full comment

Womack must have got her training via the SWP in some way or another, and the woman posing the phone in question about transgender rights was definitely an DWP plant.

Expand full comment

DWP? Dept of Work & Pensions??

Expand full comment

Sorry I didn't correct, I meant SWP! The vocal style very recognisable if you've experienced them a few times.

Expand full comment

Ha ha!!!! 😂 I think I remember that from Union conferences. Very staccato with much peppering of forceful reiterations of, "The fact is . . .etc. "!

Expand full comment

Hi Graham - how do I contact you about an elected post/holder in the Labour Party doxxing a fellow LP member, organising a pile-on & trying to remove her livelihood?

Expand full comment
author

Just reply to one of the substack emails!

Expand full comment

I’ve tried to!

Expand full comment

I used to vote Greens here in Sydney, Australia, but they have gone funny too, not as openly as in the UK. Nothing on this issue is really in the open in Australia, while it is in effects it becomes clear that there are some 't' sympathisers in big organisations, news leaders like the 'neutral' ABC, and already introduced sympathetic laws are in operation etc.etc.

Expand full comment

There are no comments whatsoever on the LBC youtube clip ....

Expand full comment

Is it so hard to tell us what a woman is?

Expand full comment