38 Comments

I've no idea what the answer is but that would be a hell of a court case.

The Scottish Government would have to claim they were lied to when someone told them humans could change their sex; a bit like complaining that you now have two broken legs after stepping off the roof because someone told you that humans could levitate.

But then a woman is actually going to court for saying women have vaginas so anything's possible.

Expand full comment
Nov 19, 2021Liked by mole at the counter

Thank you for putting this, in particular: "... allows trans rights activists to hold up slogans counteracting arguments that no-one is making. If there’s no debate, people think this is the debate." into words.

Expand full comment
Nov 19, 2021Liked by mole at the counter

Free Father Ted Bloke!

Expand full comment
Nov 19, 2021Liked by mole at the counter

Can they? I hope so. And I agree that the Father Ted bloke should be fully and publicly exonerated.

Expand full comment

Thanks for publishing this. Now have the document to hand in case my MSP takes the Nancy Kelley line......It wisnay me!

Kelley in one fell swoop has cast herself as a complete liar, can't now believe a single word in that entire interview.

Expand full comment

some comments on Thinktank McCrazypants (Twitter)

@Lady__GSoulI actually don't know how babies are born and anybody who says they do is a liar. What's more, EVERYBODY AGREES WITH ME!

Replying to @Lady__GSoulApparently it was the Stork for me, my mother and my grandmother. So my biology homework began"There has been no sexual intercourse in this family for three generations".

Replying to @Lady__GSoul and @ForwomenScotI had heard you needed a man and a woman to make a baby, but as no one knows who they are or which is which, I guess I got lucky when I got pregnant. The midwife assigned her female based on her genitals. How presumptive!

liambrunetti@liambrunetti“I actually don’t know why we put food in our mouths and not up our bumholes, nobody on this panel does. And anybody who says they do know is a liar.”

Expand full comment

Is it breach of contract - or negligence?

Money was exchanged for consultancy that was wrong - when they were supposed to be specialists/ experts! The damage they have caused can’t be brushed under the carpet- they’ve caused serious harm

Expand full comment

Transactivism is "an example of mass sociogenic illness, which involves behaviors, emotions, or conditions spreading through a group.” I read this in the Atlantic: “Munchausen by internet” describes a syndrome wherein patients pose as sick or dying in chat rooms and online support groups." Doesn't this sound familiar? "...the most vulnerable communities across the globe... “the violent deaths of 37 transgender and gender-nonconforming people” were described as an “epidemic of violence” by our president...”

https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2021/03/krug-carrillo-dolezal-social-munchausen-syndrome/618289/

The Human Rights Campaign maintains a year-by-year database containing every known case of a transgender individual being killed by violent means. In 2017 (the most violent recent year on record), there were 29 recorded murders of trans individuals, a fraction of the 17,294 murders committed that year; 26 in 2018, of 16,214 murders nationally; and 29 in 2019 of 16,425 murders nationally.

I was kicked off Medium for pointing this out.

Expand full comment

I certainly hope SW can be sued and held accountable for the major part they and their disciples played perpetuating the gender ideology myth.

Nancy Kelley and Stonewall's fingerprints are all over the mutilation of children, the erasure and harassment of women, the erasure and harassment of lesbians, the pain of families torn asunder by this dangerous ideology and the pain and ramifications of people cancelled for questioning the madness.

Kelly and Stonewall know there is a shift in public opinion and she is on a rehabilitation tour with this interview. Stonewall, Kelly and everyone who supported this dangerous ideology must be reminded everyday of their part in this horror. The damage caused by this ideology will take years to undo. Not to mention the untold number of children who will be left with shrivelled genitals and serious mental health issues.

I hope and pray this nightmare will end soon for all our mental health.

Expand full comment

ThinkTank McCrazyPants is surely an excellent advertisement for whatever schools she attended where they didn't teach even the most basic biology. And if I were as mentally challenged as she obviously is, I would be very careful calling other people liars.

Expand full comment

The Kelly Car Crash Interview of 2121 . What I took from it was there's a realistion from her , that for all the denial/obfustication ( eg around JKR ) her aruguments wither and die under decent journos questioning . There's panic there in her responses .

Expand full comment

Just read a cracking blog on the Critic comparing Stonewall to a quasi religion collecting tithes

Lol

Expand full comment

Whether Nancy Kelley either believes all her own nonsense or she's a liar, she's made herself look like a complete prat and I for one am extremely happy. This woman (oo sorry can I call her that?) has been driving this BS for the best part of 18 months and she thought she could get away with it forever, but thanks to Nolan's reporting (and now her word salad interview with Emma Barnett) she's been outed as a complete fraud, and an absolute joke. The woman is a national disgrace.

Expand full comment

Someone has uploaded the Nancy Kelley Woman's Hour Interview onto YouTube. How she wriggles and fibs! Emma Barnett did a splendid job of heading her off at the pass every time Kelley tried to make a break for it with a diversion or put up a smokescreen of flummery!

"Nancy Kelley (Stonewall UK) - 2021-11-18 - Woman's Hour - Transgender Debate"

https://youtu.be/4yNdeQQossY

Expand full comment

It's high time the Scottish government started to use its collective brain and stopped listening to a misogynistic lobby group like Stonewall . No sensible person reading those " guidelines " ( ie instructions ) could possibly believe they were fair or just !! Erasure of women is a threat to humanity ,and it they can't see that they're wilfully blind and criminal irresponsible !!

Expand full comment

I cannot understand why JKR isn't suing..

Expand full comment