It is my pleasure to present, for your delectation and delight, just a handful of the good news stories from the gender beat this week. Enjoy!
EHRC’s Double Whammy
The big news this week has to be the Equality and Human Rights Commission’s announcements. This feels like a pivotal moment in the UK’s sex/gender debate.
First, the EHRC announced that it has written to the Scottish Government, expressing concern over its proposed reform of the gender recognition act.
“The potential consequences include those relating to the collection and use of data, participation and drug testing in competitive sport, measures to address barriers facing women, and practices within the criminal justice system, inter alia. As such, we consider that more detailed consideration is needed before any change is made to the provisions in the Act.”
Immediately after making this statement, the EHCR then published its response to the UK government’s conversion therapy consultation.
It calls for pre-legislative scrutiny and expresses concerns about definitions of key terms such as ‘conversion therapy’ and ‘transgender’.
Furthermore, just a few days later, we learned that the EHRC intervened in the row over the Scottish Census ‘sex question’.
The EHRC wrote to Scottish Census officials to inform that requiring trans-identified people to accurately record their sex does not breach their legal right to privacy. "Where there is a requirement in statute, such as for the census, any potential interference with Article 8 [right to privacy] arising from collecting data on sex is likely to be justified”
Tavistock & Portman Found Wanting
Another important piece of news this week concerns a review of the governance of the Tavistock & Portman, the NHS trust responsible for the Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS).
The external report states that, “The scale of the corporate governance issues we have identified across the Trust are multiple”. These issues are detailed in Hannah Barnes’ excellent thread.
The trust’s board is being asked to accept the review’s various recommendations. Meanwhile, the current Chair, Paul Burstow, will be stepping down in April.
Lia Lia, Trunks On Fire
The Lia Thomas controversy just won’t go away with yet more sporting ‘names’ speaking out against his inclusion on the UPenn women’s swimming team.
This week a leading and award-winning coach added his voice to the dissenters.
Seth Huston is the Rice University swim coach. In an interview with SwimSwam, he criticised the policy that allows Thomas to compete with females. “I just feel like we’re bowing to, in this particular instance, to one person. And really to the detriment of thousands of other athletes potentially. And I don’t think that’s right.”
Caitlin Jenner has also spoken out on this issue. (He’s probably not our favourite person on these pages but, credit where it’s due, he is right about this!)
"I am firmly behind protecting women's sports, we cannot have biological boys competing against women in women's sports... We need a fair playing field.”
The Toronto Star also published an article about the athletes speaking out against Thomas competing on the women’s team.
“What’s becoming increasingly obvious is that the entirely commendable objective of promoting gender inclusion in sports is destroying fair play and erasing females.”
Great News From Sex Matters
Sex Matters has announced its new advisory group.
“Sex matters in every walk of life, in very obvious ways and more subtle ones. Our advisory group members represent a wide range of personal and professional experiences and links to wider networks.”
Northern Women Won’t Wheesht
A splendid demonstration by the wonderful women of the Northern Rad Fem Network who protested against the housing of males in female prisons outside HMP Styal in Cheshire.
Strength and solidarity to you, sisters. Keep up the brilliant work.
Phew! Although aware of a lot of the above, I just like seeing a 'good news supplement'. The headline alone cheers me up.
Janice Turner is, as always, brilliant and I'm pleased to say, she is very popular at The Times if the comments on her columns are anything to go by. Her contributions alone justify my subscription.
Great about coach Seth Huston. Let's hope more professionals follow.
Protesters in the UK, I salute you for your bravery and stamina in going out in the freezing cold to stand up for all of us ultimately.
These keep getting better and better! New edition of Private Eye reports Ladies and Lords "furious" at gender extremist BS: https://ibb.co/MgdsWDb