19 Comments
User's avatar
Friki's avatar

What a truly excellent article. I will share it. I am one of the parents upon whom that pernicious canard was bestowed: "Would you rather have a dead son or a live daughter?" It took years of struggle, in silence, navigating around compromised schools, physicians, and therapists - with support from only that brave cadre of fellow parents online and an honest therapist who bravely risked his career - but today I have a live son, a strong and wonderful son. Doctor B******* W********, who tried to emotionally blackmail me into castrating my son, may he never sleep through the night again; the blood of children will never leave his hands. My healthy son is now working to end the practice of youth gender transition, and he is meeting the very best people. The author of this piece is in esteemed company.

Patrick Young's avatar

Bravo! I was a GP from 1988 - 2018. I think that any medical professional who participates in poisoning and mutilating delusional children should be struck off and jailed.

Jeremy Wickins's avatar

Thank you, Dr Anonymous, for this clear and concise essay on practical medical ethics. As an ex-lecturer in medical law and ethics, this is exactly what I would be telling medical students (if I were allowed to touch the subject in the current medical school environment). You are a credit to your profession.

Tenaciously Terfin's avatar

Superb, thank you. I hope this inspires more doctors to question the ideology and understand the harm that it is causing.

Rebecca Says No's avatar

Worth noting that we are also very open to hearing from doctors in other specialties who may wish to write an article.

Tenaciously Terfin's avatar

I’m not a doctor but many people I know have children in the NHS. Will put out some feelers but as I’m sure you’ll understand, at least some of them already regard me as ‘unclean’.

Giulia Hunt's avatar

Terrific open letter. This GP is to be applauded for his understanding of how the pathway is nothing but a rocky road where, "there be dragons". I have saved it, and would actually like to print and drop copies off to local GP surgeries. The airplane analogy is excellent! Thank you so much for sharing.

Rebecca Says No's avatar

The author has let me know that this was their intention and they would be very happy if people do send this article to GPs.

Ute Heggen's avatar

I wondered if females develop urinary incontinence due to the atrophy effects of testosterone. Males on estrogen also experience urinary incontinence, as confirmed by detransitioner Ray Alex Williams. The estradiol, usually prescribed in very high doses, causes muscle weakness in the pelvic floor, leading to urinary leaks. Ray said no doctor ever warned him of this. But then, they recommended he continue on this wrong sex hormone even after being hospitalized for pancreatitis and then surviving a pulmonary embolism because it occurred while he was in hospital. How these doctors justify this recommendation, I can't explain.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XGuQpt-i6O4

Marlo Manners's avatar

This is so good and very encouraging. This GP is absolutely correct in their responsibilities to their patients.

Mollie Kaye's avatar

I wish this GP would go public. I predict a large shift would occur if more sensible people in all walks of life stated the obvious, but physicians are the people who have the most influence on how laypeople and parents see these elective, experimental loss-of-function cosmetic chemical and surgical sex trait modifications for children and vulnerable youth.

Ollie Parks's avatar

This courageous piece speaks truth to power. Unfortunately, the entrenched trans activist establishment in the U.S. has the influence to ignore the warnings and recommendations of learned physicians like this anonymous writer. The gender identity movement can draw upon well-placed allies with vast resources to discredit knowledgeable and experienced professionals. Look at how they manufactured the illusion that the elite and powerful Yale Law School had decisively dismantled the Cass Review. In reality, the deeply flawed paper titled "The Cass Review and the Fate of Gender Medicine" was not an official Yale Law publication—it merely carried the prestige of the institution to lend it undue credibility.

From a gender-critical perspective, "The Cass Review and the Fate of Gender Medicine" fails to engage meaningfully with the medical, ethical, and scientific concerns raised by Cass. Instead, it politicizes the issue, misrepresents her findings, and prioritizes ideological commitments over patient well-being. Yet how many well intentioned trans allies who parrot its criticisms of the Cass Review even realize this? If gender-critical activists do not act swiftly to engage centrists and liberals—while challenging trans activists' dominance in shaping the narrative—the Cass Review may fade into obscurity. Meanwhile, members of the gender affirming helping professions will continue to confront distraught parents with the same false choice: a living trans son or a dead daughter.

gadflybytes's avatar

It’s shocking how little evidence is even seen by many in our supposedly science-based society. Media suppresses everything that doesn’t support a specific dominant narrative, while paywalls separate many from the science driving policy.

We are told consensus is more important than exploration through disagreement and then compromise. Gender identity is just one topic for which consensus has been determined by a shadowy They (they/them pronouns). .

Climate change is another such topic. The dominant thesis of CC is that it is of human cause AND directly and only the result of CO2 concentration is another tenet. The dominant ‘therefore, we shall’ of said theory is that we must eliminate all carbon emissions.

Excuse me? Shall we also stop breathing? Not yet, They assure us, not as long as you give up meat and eat crickets. There is a carbon cycle as is there a water cycle. Managing it.is something we should work harder doing, but eliminating it is impossible.

Battery technologies are insufficient to replace hydrocarbons as energy storage devices. As they currently exist, they are unstable, short lived and ultimately unsustainable.

As far as electric cars and other transport modes, we are also flying the plane while building it. They have determined we will transition everything to wind and solar generated electricity, based on manipulated data and a mediascape dominated by marketing materials disguised as ‘journalism’.

Everything from covid lockdowns, mask and jab mandates, to gender identity and forced decarbonization is being massaged, managed and manipulated to press us collectively down a dark and superstitious path.

We must reinvigorate free speech and lively debates, so we may dissect truth from lies, and send mis, dis and malinformation to the dustbin of humanity’s Orwellian period. Only in this manner can we crack open the fortress of ignorance, and its concommitant temple based edicts from high priests of The Science™️, which has been erected between us and reality.

Dusty Masterson's avatar

Thanks for bringing us this important piece. We need more and more people to put their head above the parapet!

Have cross posted

https://dustymasterson.substack.com/p/a-song-is-born-part-1

Dusty

Mumbum's avatar

Great to read this today, in the Guardian of all places! Is the mainstream ‘left’ finally waking up?? Useful to help peak your most wilfully ignorant / virtue signally critics https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2025/mar/23/the-observer-view-on-gender-failure-to-accurately-record-biological-sex-harms-us-all?CMP=share_btn_url

Rebecca Says No's avatar

No that is their sister paper The Observer which is only out on a Sunday. I bet it goes down very badly in the Guardian offices, but is brilliant on this topic.

Mumbum's avatar

True - but it IS on the Guardian website- wonders never cease! I wonder why now? Would be interesting to know what peaked them?